Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers of All Time

The Premier League has witnessed some remarkable penalty takers known for their calmness and accuracy under pressure. Alan Shearer leads with 56 successful penalties, while Yaya Touré holds an unblemished record. Other notable names include Matt Le Tissier and Harry Kane, both admired for their consistency. New talents like Cole Palmer and Erling Haaland are carrying forward this tradition. These players blend skill, nerve, and precision to make their mark from the spot, cementing their place among the best penalty takers in Premier League history.

Scoring from a penalty remains one of the most reliable methods to put the ball in the net. Since the Premier League's inception, numerous players have mastered this art. Many of these athletes have earned their reputations through calm finishes during high-pressure moments. Taking penalties requires more than just skill; it demands sharp intellect and nerves of steel. English star Harry Kane has often relied on his penalty prowess in his quest for the Golden Boot. The question remains: who truly are the Premier League's finest penalty takers?

Though many have stepped up, only a select few possess the composure to convert when it counts most. We have compiled a list of the top 10 Premier League penalty takers of all time based on their records and impact.

Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers

• Rank: 10 Player: Bukayo Saka Clubs: Arsenal Active Years: 2019–Present Penalties Scored: 12
• Rank: 9 Player: James Beattie Clubs: Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, Stoke City Active Years: 1998–2010 Penalties Scored: 16
• Rank: 8 Player: Callum Wilson Clubs: Bournemouth, Newcastle United Active Years: 2014–Present Penalties Scored: 16
• Rank: 7 Player: Erling Haaland Clubs: Manchester City Active Years: 2022–Present Penalties Scored: 20
• Rank: 6 Player: Danny Murphy Clubs: Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, Fulham Active Years: 1997–2013 Penalties Scored: 18
• Rank: 5 Player: Harry Kane Clubs: Tottenham Hotspur Active Years: 2012–2023 Penalties Scored: 33
• Rank: 4 Player: Cole Palmer Clubs: Manchester City, Chelsea Active Years: 2021–Present Penalties Scored: 18
• Rank: 3 Player: Matt Le Tissier Clubs: Southampton Active Years: 1992–2002 Penalties Scored: 25
• Rank: 2 Player: Yaya Touré Clubs: Manchester City Active Years: 2010–2018 Penalties Scored: 11
• Rank: 1 Player: Alan Shearer Clubs: Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle United Active Years: 1992–2006 Penalties Scored: 56

Examining the Greatest Premier League Penalty Experts

Kicking a penalty in front of thousands in a stadium packed with fans is no simple task, especially in the world’s top football league. It demands nerves of steel. Our top 10 list features those who have consistently performed under such pressure.

10. Bukayo Saka (Forward | England)

After missing a penalty in the Euro 2020 final, Bukayo Saka transformed from being doubted into a dependable penalty taker for Arsenal. With a conversion rate of about 92%, he has scored 12 out of 13 penalties, establishing himself as a key figure in the North London club’s attack.

• Appearances: 223
• Goals: 59
• Penalties Scored: 12
• Conversion Rate: 92%

9. James Beattie (Striker | England)

James Beattie played for multiple Premier League clubs including Southampton and Everton, showing deadly accuracy from the spot. He netted 16 goals from 17 attempts, missing only once in 2006 without impacting the outcome negatively.

• Appearances: 270
• Goals: 90
• Penalties Scored: 16
• Conversion Rate: 94%

8. Callum Wilson (Striker | England)

Callum Wilson has been a trusted penalty taker since his days at Bournemouth, carrying that form through Newcastle and West Ham. His calmness has led to 16 successful penalties from 17 attempts.

• Appearances: 267
• Goals: 94
• Penalties Scored: 16
• Conversion Rate: 94%

7. Erling Haaland (Forward | Norway)

The prolific Erling Haaland makes scoring penalties look effortless. At Manchester City, he has scored 20 out of 23 spot kicks, missing only three times, regardless of the game's stakes.

• Appearances: 129
• Goals: 109
• Penalties Scored: 20
• Conversion Rate: 87%

6. Danny Murphy (Midfielder | England)

Danny Murphy was nearly perfect from the spot, missing only once in his Premier League career. Despite Joe Hart denying him, Murphy earned respect for his precise finishes while playing for clubs like Liverpool and Fulham.

• Appearances: 417
• Goals: 66
• Penalties Scored: 18
• Conversion Rate: 95%

5. Harry Kane (Forward | England)

Harry Kane ranks among the elite penalty takers. During his time at Tottenham Hotspur, he converted 33 penalties out of 37, showcasing his reliability despite a slightly lower conversion rate of 89%.

• Appearances: 320
• Goals: 213
• Penalties Scored: 33
• Conversion Rate: 89%

4. Cole Palmer (Attacking Midfielder | England)

Cole Palmer maintained near perfection with 18 penalties scored out of 19 attempts between Manchester City and Chelsea. His composure under pressure is remarkable despite recently missing against Leicester City.

• Appearances: 111
• Goals: 46
• Penalties Scored: 18
• Conversion Rate: 95%

3. Matt Le Tissier (Forward | England)

Legendary Southampton player Matt Le Tissier converted 24 of his 25 penalties, earning the nickname “Le God.” His only miss was against Nottingham Forest in 1993 during a decade-long career filled with 101 goals in 270 appearances.

• Appearances: 270
• Goals: 101
• Penalties Scored: 24
• Conversion Rate: 96%

2. Yaya Touré (Midfielder | Ivory Coast)

Yaya Touré stands out with a flawless penalty record, scoring all 11 attempts during his time at Manchester City. His composed technique rarely involved dummies and frequently left goalkeepers helpless.

• Appearances: 230
• Goals: 62
• Penalties Scored: 11
• Conversion Rate: 100%

1. Alan Shearer (Forward | England)

Alan Shearer tops the list with 56 penalties scored for Blackburn Rovers and Newcastle United. Despite missing over 10 spot kicks, his sheer goal-scoring ability and clutch performances make him the Premier League's greatest penalty taker.

• Appearances: 441
• Goals: 260
• Penalties Scored: 56
• Conversion Rate: 84%

Frequently Asked Questions

• Who is the Premier League’s greatest penalty taker?Alan Shearer holds the top spot as the best penalty taker in Premier League history.
• Is Erling Haaland among the top 10 Premier League penalty takers? Yes, Erling Haaland ranks seventh on this list.
• Who are the top three Premier League penalty takers? They are Alan Shearer, Yaya Touré, and Matt Le Tissier.
• Where does Erling Haaland stand among EPL’s best penalty takers? He is seventh on the all-time list.